Nature, Scope and POSDCORB
How nature and scope differ, and what POSDCORB does and does not explain.
Nature and scope answer different questions
Nature concerns what is included in administration and what kind of activity it is. Scope concerns the range of activities and questions covered by the field. The integral-managerial distinction and the executive-all branches distinction are separate: one classifies work, while the other identifies the governmental arena.
| Dimension | Integral view | Managerial view |
|---|---|---|
| Work included | Managerial, technical, clerical and operational contributions to administrative purpose. | Planning, organisation, direction and other coordinating or managerial activities. |
| Attention | How all necessary contributions produce the service. | How work is organised and directed. |
| Hospital example | Nursing, diagnosis, records, supplies and supervision all contribute. | Scheduling staff, allocating resources, coordination and control receive central attention. |
| Limit if treated as exhaustive | Can become too broad to isolate managerial problems. | Can neglect technical knowledge, frontline judgment and actual service experience. |
POSDCORB is a managerial framework
Gulick used POSDCORB to organise the functions of the chief executive. It is a useful way of asking whether essential managerial tasks have been addressed. It is not a complete account of public purposes, political power, technical knowledge or administrative behaviour.
| Function | Meaning | Illustration in a vaccination programme |
|---|---|---|
| Planning | Determine objectives and methods. | Identify target groups and delivery arrangements. |
| Organising | Arrange roles and authority. | Allocate responsibilities among health units. |
| Staffing | Recruit develop and deploy personnel. | Provide trained vaccinators and support staff. |
| Directing | Guide decisions and action. | Issue operational instructions and resolve uncertainty. |
| Coordinating | Integrate interdependent contributions. | Align supply transport staffing and outreach. |
| Reporting | Maintain and communicate relevant information. | Report coverage shortages and adverse events. |
| Budgeting | Plan finance and exercise financial control. | Provide resources track expenditure and account for use. |
Why subject matter matters
A hospital and a police organisation both budget and recruit, but competent management also needs different substantive knowledge. Public health involves clinical safety and epidemiology; policing involves investigation, evidence and lawful coercion. Generic management cannot replace this expertise. The subject-matter approach therefore complements common managerial functions rather than denying them.
The scope of administration as an activity expands with public responsibilities. The discipline, however, needs an organising focus on public institutions, policy, authority, behaviour and accountability. A growing role for government does not mean every subject becomes indistinguishably Public Administration.
Why does POSDCORB provide a useful but incomplete account of Public Administration?
Answer direction Explain its managerial contribution, then add subject expertise, policy, public values, informal relations and citizen experience.
Previous: Note 1: Meaning and the Public Character of Administration | Next: Note 3: Public and Private Administration and Significance
π£ Join our community